Seared Beef Fillet Sarnie

Cooking time:     30 mins
Serves:                 2

What you need

2 John Penny fillet steaks, total weight 300-350g
1 plump garlic clove, crushed
1 tbsp finely chopped oregano
good pinch of dried crushed chillies
black pepper
2 tbsp olive oil, plus extra for brushing
Bread of your choice
2 tbsp soured cream
1 tbsp creamed horseradish sauce
watercress sprigs
85g drained sunblush red peppers from a jar
a few small capers

How to cook

Lay the beef in a non-metallic shallow dish. Stir the garlic, oregano, chillies and some pepper into the olive oil.  Pour it over the beef, rubbing it in to coat both sides. Leave to marinate for at least 10 minutes.

Brush both sides of the bread with a little extra oil. Heat a griddle pan then cook the bread on it until lightly toasted on each side. Set aside.

Lift the beef from the marinade and lay it on the hot griddle. Cook for 2-2½ minutes on each side for medium rare, 2½-3 minutes for medium and 3-3½ for well done. Remove and let the meat rest for 5 minutes.

Mix the soured cream and horseradish together.  Scatter some watercress sprigs onto each slice of bread, then drizzle a line of the horseradish cream mixture down the middle.

Lay the sunblush peppers casually on top and scatter over a few capers.  Slice the beef quite thinly, then arrange it in a line over the peppers. Season, and serve 2 slices per person.

Cook's tip: For a more intense flavour, the beef can be marinated overnight, and then quickly cooked on the griddle or barbecue when ready to serve. Just remove from the fridge 30 minutes before cooking.

Click here to pre-order our cookbook
Why not submit one of your own recipes?
  • Follow us on twitter
  • Find us on Facebook